Judging a Masterpiece Quilt

What is the Masterpiece Award, and what do the judges look for when selecting a recipient? NQA Certified Quilt Judge, Beverly Fine, shares some insight into the process.

How does a NACQJ quilt judge designate a Masterpiece Quilt?
by Beverly Fine
NQA Certified Quilt Judge

In 1980, certified quilt judges created a special honor for quilts that surpass the highest expectations for development of design and exemplary workmanship.  As these judges travel the country while judging large and small quilt shows, they are on the lookout for quilts that could be evaluated as possible Masterpieces.  There are only a few absolute requirements for a quilt to be nominated for an evaluation: that the quilt be at least 25 sq. ft. in size, that the quilt must have been completed within the previous five years, and that the quiltmaker(s) be living. 

In considering a nomination, a judge is not looking for perfection, but they are looking for a quilt that will stand the test of time.  Colors can be subtly shaded, as in Diane Guadynski’s “Through a Glass Darkly”, or high chroma, as in the case of  Pat Holly’s “Saffron Splendor”.

Designs can be elegant and classically traditional, such as Gail Stepanek and Jan Hutchinson’s “Cardinal Points”, or charming and whimsical such as Mary Buvia’s “The Loading Dock”.

Some characteristics are shared among the winners, such as intricate details, excellent contrast, a sense of proportion and harmony, and the freshness and creativity born of an experienced quiltmaker.

Shirley Kelley’s story of a series of quilts leading up to “Flowers of the Crown” bears this out. These are the quilts that cause a gasp upon first glance and demand a much longer viewing to take in all that is shown.

In all, 34 quilts have been designated Masterpieces.  These quiltmakers share the knowledge that they have achieved the very highest distinction among award winners.  Collectively, their names are a veritable “Who’s Who” in the quilting community.

A quiltmaker may also nominate their own quilt for evaluation as a Masterpiece for a small fee.  When a nomination is accepted, a team of five certified judges then evaluates the quilt.  The evaluation is highly structured and usually lasts almost two hours to complete.  A full evaluation is then written and sent to the quiltmaker, whether the quilt achieves a Masterpiece designation or not.  Quiltmakers appreciate the detailed and positive nature of the feedback.  Up to three quilts per year are accepted for evaluation.

Look here for more information about the National Association of Certified Quilt Judges.